This picture was taken immediately after making this batch. It actually thickens to a nice fluffy consistency as it cools in the refrigerator!
I have been on the quest to find a nutritious alternative to the store bought versions of mayonnaise that come filled with soybean or canola oil, two genetically modified ingredients that are best to be avoided. Read more about GMO’s here. I have tried a few different homemade varieties and have shared them here in the past, but either they tasted too strongly of olive oil or else they used evaporated milk. Enter…coconut oil!
A combination of olive oil and coconut oil is the perfect balance to providing a high quality and nutritious mayonnaise. (Read more about these healthy oils here.) Can you believe it? Mayonnaise can actually be healthy for you! We love mayo at our house on everything from deviled eggs, sandwiches, hamburgers, etc. This recipe is a good balance of coconut oil and olive oil in flavor. It is quite delicious! The coconut oil adds just a slight sweetness to it and yet not overpowering when balanced with the olive oil. Using all coconut oil resulted in a solid substance that was overly sweet and coconut tasting, but this recipe was prefect for us and stayed nice and fluffy throughout its duration in the fridge. I love making my own condiments as I know what goes in it without any additives or unnatural preservatives! Plus it is the frugal way to stretch your budget.
1 whole egg (fresh, free range eggs from the farm are preferred)
2 egg yolks
1 Tablespoon Dijon mustard
1 Tablespoon lemon juice
1/4-1/2 teaspoon sea salt
1/4 teaspoon white pepper
1/3 cup extra virgin coconut oil (melted if solid)
2/3 cup extra virgin olive oil
Combine the eggs, mustard, lemon juice, salt and white pepper in your blender or food processor. Then with the blender or food processor running on a low speed, start adding your oils very slowly. Start out with drops and then work up to about a 1/16 inch stream. It takes a good 5 minutes to accomplish this, but the end result is worth it! Continue blending until all the oil is incorporated.
Makes about 1 1/2 cups. Please in your refrigerator to thicken. Store in an airtight container for up to two weeks. You can add 1 Tablespoon of whey to preserve it for about a month and provide those good fermenting nutrients.
Note: If you do not like the flavor of coconut oil, choose an expeller pressed/refined version. This is flavorless and still healthy, although not as beneficial for your body as the cold-pressed, unrefined versions. I love Mountain Rose Herbs coconut oil, and they sell both varieties. Another good alternative is sesame oil, although again not as nutritious as coconut oil.
Recipe is adapted slightly from Tropical Traditions.
P.S. Looks like I am not the only one thinking about and experimenting with homemade mayo lately. Check out Kelly the Kitchen Kop’s healthy recipe here.
I recently made the switch to all glass. I had...
I’ve been thinking about trying mayo-making! How long does this last in the fridge?
Oh, thank you for posting this! We love mayo around here & it has been the last item w/ soybean oil that we have not eliminated from our diet. I’ve tried a few organic versions but not only did they had the bad oils, they tasted yucky. Looking forward to trying this one!
I am a totally amorous coconut oil fan after reading your blog! It’s the best stuff – and I appreciate all of the information you’ve provided about it. THIS recipe is great! We all love mayo in our house – but we all know how bad it is (and now I know even moreso) – what a great alternative for us! Thank you.
I just wanted to know if the coconut oil you use has a coconut flavor or smell to it? Thanks!
Susan
Yes, I use cold pressed virgin coconut oil from Mountain Rose Herbs as it is a high quality nutritious oil. It does not really smell but definitely has a pleasant coconut flavor to it.
Is there one you would recommend that does NOT have a coconut taste to it? or is it just best to use a palm oil, or does that too, have a flavor to it?
The best alternative would be sesame oil.
hmmm I thought sesame oil had a taste to it too.
I was actually just checking out Tropical Traditions recipes today! I’m really excited about trying this. I also am really glad that I stumbled upon your blog. I’ve been trying to find a way to make soap without glycerin or lye, and your website was the first that I found that mentioned soap nuts. I got my sample in the mail yesterday, and I’m trying it for the first time tonight…here’s hoping it works!
P.S. Your children are beautiful. I just had my first little boy and he’s almost 10 months old. What a joy and delight!!!
I’m beginning to think you can find a way to make anything with coconut oil in it:)
this is really wild, because just the last two or three days I’ve been searching for a homemade mayo recipe and been contemplating investing in some real cold pressed olive oil (http://www.living-foods.com/articles/oliveoil.html) and low and behold, several other people are on the same quest as I. Thanks for sharing this recipe, I bought some coconut oil a few weeks ago after learning about it on your blog, so I’m happy to know I can add this to my first attempt at my own mayo! (it actually all started when I wanted some ranch for my homegrown salad on Wednesday, and couldn’t bear to put all that artificial junk on my salad.)
You’ve probably written about this in the past, but I’m wondering if the health benefits are still great enough to warrant using the expeller pressed coconut oil. I haven’t liked the strong flavor of the extra-virgin but am currently using expeller pressed for baking, cooking and skin care. I have searched online for information but wonder what your opinion is as I’m sure you’ve checked it out thoroughly?!
Yes, cold pressed virgin coconut oil is by far the most superior in nutrients, but I believe expeller pressed is still superior to canola or other baking oils based on soy. There are differing opinions though, as MRH specifically states here that expeller pressed coconut oil should only be used for cosmetic purposes. Have you tried just a virgin coconut oil? Extra virgin would definitely be more powerful on the coconut flavor side. The kind the MRH carries is just virgin.
I’m looking forward to trying this. We love Mayo here, but I hate giving it to my family because I know it’s so bad.
A question: Can you add kefir to it instead of Whey to preserve?
If you drain the kefir, the liquid you have is kefir whey which is perfectly suitable. This recipe only makes a little over a cup so it is used up relatively quickly anyway, before it could go bad.
Could I make this with an immersion blender? I’ve been using your recipe with the canned milk and am excited to try this one!
Yes, definitely!
Are the eggs raw, or do you cook them first?
I use raw free range local eggs and don’t cook them prior to use. From what I understand, the blending process heats them enough to pasteurize them, as you are blending the product for several minutes.
Thanks for this, Lindsay! We love the mayo that I usually make, but it doesn’t work on my hubby’s current diet and we still have 3 months to go until he’s finished with it. This recipe actually fits with the diet- amazing!
Can’t wait to surprise him with mayo that he can eat without guilt!
Hi Lindsay!
Yes, how fun that we’ve both been playing with our mayo recipes! Many commenters at my post have said they’re having good luck (and it takes less time) when they use the immersion blender that Susanna asked about. I can’t wait to try it! If the coconut oil/olive oil flavors are still a bit strong for anyone, you can try what I use: sesame oil. Coconut oil is more nutritious, but only if your family will eat it, and mine won’t, not in their mayo anyway!
I appreciate the links!!
Kelly
Nourishing Gourmet shows how to do it with the immersion blender (which I just got for my birthday!) Can’t wait to try this out.
http://www.thenourishinggourmet.com/2008/04/homemade-mayonnaise-2.html
You can use an immersion blender but it is not necessary. Yes, Kimi is a real friend of mine and Amy is my cousin!
I have tried the olive oil and didn’t like it, so I am excited to try this! Thanks for the recipe.
Thank you so much for this recipe! I eliminated soy pretty much from my diet about four months ago to help with my migraines. It was not that hard for me to eliminate everything with soy until summer came along. There are just so many things we eat during the summer that require mayo. I just did not have time to search out an alternative this summer. If I get this recipe to work I will get to eat our normal summer faire again without fear of headaches. Yeah!
By the way, I have needed info or recipes on many other things in the past year that you “just happen” to provide within a month of my starting to think about each topic. Thank you so much for the your time researching and putting the information together in your blog to share with the rest of us. I really appreciate it!
I tried this mayo. recipe this morning and it turned out beautifully! I used a mix of extra virgin olive oil, expeller pressed coconut oil, and a little safflower oil. I have noticed that a few other blender recipes call for just one egg and more lemon juice/and or vinegar. Do you find that using three eggs is a necessity for the mayo. to have the right consistency?
Thanks so much!
Three eggs seems to give it more of a creamy texture. More vinegar/lemon juice just gave it more of a strong flavor, but you can experiment as desired.
This was good but some in my family still think it has too strong of an olive oil taste… have you ever tried doing 2/3 coconut & 1/3 olive oil? Also, can I decrease the Dijon a bit?
Yes, I have tried it with more coconut oil as you described and found it too powerful on the coconut flavor side. You may like it just fine that way, so give it a try. And yes, you can definitely decrease the dijon as desired.
Hi Lindsay. I replied to the evaporated milk recipe because my son can only have raw milk products. You referred me to your new coconut mayo recipe. Well, he can’t have coconut or sesame either. Do you think that this can be made with grapeseed oil? In the evaporated milk recipe do you think that raw cream might work? Thank you again for all of your help! Melanie
Can he have olive oil? If so, you can easily make this entirely with olive oil. You could try replacing the evaporated milk with raw cream if you desire, but I am not sure at how well it would work. I have not tried it.
Thank you Lindsay. I’ll give it a shot and let you know how it turns out.
We are LOVING this recipe- I make it w/ half olive oil & 1/2 refined coconut oil w/ a bit less mustard. YUM! Thank you so much!
GREAT recipe! Thanks for sharing. I have been trying to use only olive oil and coconut oil in my cooking, so this worked great for me!
I think I’ll try adding some garlic and herbs next time too! Thanks again!
Stacy McDonald
http://www.passionatehousewives.blogspot.com/
Has anyone tried adding some cold-pressed flax seed oil to this? It would amp up the nutritional value even more, and if you use cold-pressed organic (like Spectrum), you can’t take that ‘flaxy’ flavor.
I actually make a mayo with no other oils but flax, and it’s great! (I am on a special diet right now and can use no other oils at the moment, but I look forward to switching up to an olive/flax oil blend…and some coconut, too!)
Yes, it has a taste but does not taste like coconut. You will have to experiment to your liking!