Passionate Homemaking

Living simply in order to give generously

Microwave vs. Toaster Oven

from the kitchen, nutrition Add comments

Grow­ing up my mom always made us stand a few feet away from the microwave while it was on. I always won­dered why? Some­thing about the fumes coming out of the microwave? Sound famil­iar?

I read this arti­cle recently that informed me that you can pre­pare and cook prac­ti­cally any­thing in the microwave. Their rea­sons - it is fast! This con­cerned me greatly. First off, why are we in such a rush to have our food pre­pared in 1 minute? Why not slow down and enjoy the gift of life and the process of prepar­ing qual­ity food for your family? Does it con­cern you at all that you can cook pota­toes in four min­utes with the microwave? Doesn’t that seem a little unnat­ural? It does indeed use the least amount of elec­tric­ity in the kitchen (although the dif­fer­ences are min­i­mal, as described here - $0.04 per kwh vs. $0.10 for toaster oven, & $0.20 for elec­tric oven), but it’s rapid cook­ing power might just cause some problems.

This arti­cle was inter­est­ing (sorry, made an error on the links previously):

Microwaves are thought to destroy and deform food mol­e­cules. In fact, one study pub­lished in the Jour­nal of the Sci­ence of Food and Agri­cul­ture found that broc­coli “zapped” in the microwave with a little water lost up to 97 per­cent of the ben­e­fi­cial antiox­i­dant chem­i­cals it contains.

So what’s the rush to pos­si­bly destroy some of the nutri­tional value of your food? Other con­cerns have been pos­si­ble con­nec­tion to cancer, brain tumors, immune system defi­cien­cies, and the list goes on. There is indeed much con­tro­versy over the health con­cerns of microwaves, and I am not totally con­vinced of the harm­ful­ness of its use, but I am just pro­vid­ing some food for thought, and maybe we should all step back and con­sider. Why would Russia ban the use of microwaves in 1976? Inter­est­ing to note.

Fur­ther Reading:

Microwave Menace
Vegis Lose Antiox­i­dants in Microwave

Hidden Haz­ards - Microwave Oven

Benefits of the Toaster Oven

We bought a toaster oven off Craigslist for just $20, and I love it for the fol­low­ing reasons:

1. Heats food slowly and nat­u­rally like a stan­dard oven.
2. Uses less elec­tric­ity than stan­dard oven - for a small family, you can bake prac­ti­cally any­thing in it for far less time, because it doesn’t have to heat up such a large space, as in an oven. This results in using less elec­tric­ity (although the dif­fer­ences are not dras­ti­cally sig­nif­i­cant). I bake casseroles, toast bread, reheat left­overs, and thaw food (on those for­get­ful days!) all in my toaster oven!

3. Sim­pli­fies your kitchen - no need for a toaster or a microwave, and even an oven at times! Why do we need so many dif­fer­ent appli­ances and gad­gets? Why not sim­plify by choic­ing options that can accom­plish two or more tasks in one!
4. Don’t have to heat up the whole kitchen!
Espe­cially on a hot day, this is a great alter­na­tive than the oven!
5. Works as a warm­ing oven
- keep already cooked food warm before serv­ing! Another advan­tage is when you have mul­ti­ple things need­ing to be baked, when need­ing to cook two things at dif­fer­ent tem­per­a­tures -
6. Easy clean up! If some­thing spills, you simply pull out the tray!
7. Great for small places and rea­son­ably priced!

Just some things to consider…

Works for me!

Related Posts

14 Responses to “Microwave vs. Toaster Oven”

  1. Andrea Says:

    I love my toaster oven. I’d much rather use it than a toaster too–I can melt butter and cheese on the bread while it toasts!

    I’d love to com­pletely replace my microwave with my toaster oven and stove top. I had to when I lived in Russia, so I know it can be done! I’m work­ing on my own meal plan­ning habits to give myself time to bake pota­toes, for exam­ple, with­out rely­ing on the microwave to get it done in time. I think though, if I had some­one in my family with cancer (like Stephanie@keeperofthehome), I would be toss­ing my microwave out the window as fast as I could.

    Two quick things though: despite it’s small size, a toaster oven does not cook any faster than an oven. I guess men­tally I keep think­ing it will act like a microwave. I have seen some upscale models that are “convection toaster ovens” and those might be an inter­est­ing com­pro­mise for some­one really look­ing to replace their mocrowave. Second, I started a small fire in my toaster oven when I placed some­thing directly on the rack that dripped. The grease drip (from cheese, I think) landed on the heat­ing ele­ment and flamed up. For­tu­nately, I was right there and so was my hus­band. We unplugged it, removed the food, and took it out­side very quickly avert­ing any seri­ous con­se­quences (the toaster even still works great). Now I don’t cook any­thing directly on the rack that might drip, but use the small pan built for it; I always stay with it while it’s oper­at­ing; and (just in case) I make sure that it is clean inside with no crumbs and food pieces on the bottom that could fuel a fire.

    [Reply]

    Lindsay replied on April 30th, 2008:

    I don’t under­stand why your toaster oven doesn’t work faster than the stan­dard oven, because mine sure does! I have cooked baked pota­toes in my toaster oven for 20-25 min­utes, that would nor­mally take at least 45 min­utes in my stan­dard oven. I also have baked sev­eral small casseroles (8×8) for about 3/4 the time required in the oven. So it has worked for me!

    As far as elim­i­nat­ing the microwave, it does just take a little think­ing ahead. I begin in the morn­ing by asking myself what I need for the meals for today and tomor­row (menu plan­ning is essen­tial!). Any­thing frozen gets placed on the counter or refrig­er­a­tor! Stephanie @ Keeper of the Home posted her tips for quick thaw­ing and stuff here.

    I have found the toaster oven effec­tively de-​thaws most things, so I never need the microwave now! Just yes­ter­day, I thawed out a frozen bagel in my toaster oven! Worked great in just 5-10 min!

    [Reply]

  2. Linds Says:

    Thanks for this infor­ma­tion. We have both but I never got the hang of using a toaster oven. I may try again. How do you cook your pota­toes in it? Do you wrap them in any­thing?
    Thanks!
    Linds

    [Reply]

    Lindsay replied on April 30th, 2008:

    I bake every­thing as I would in a reg­u­lar oven. I put the pota­toes on a plate/glass pan (mine didn’t come with a tray), after having pierced them with a fork, and set the timer to bake for 25-30 min. I check it every once in awhile as normal. I try to avoid alu­minum wrap as much as pos­si­ble.

    [Reply]

  3. Elizabeth Says:

    I would cau­tion against making such hasty deci­sions regard­ing microwaves. Many anti-​microwave people out there have little actual sci­ence to back up their posi­tions. Fur­ther­more, the arti­cle linked above is taken com­pletely out of con­text. There are many arti­cles linked from Wikipedia, includ­ing this one from Cor­nell and the New York Times, which state the exact oppo­site, and pro­vide clar­i­fi­ca­tion to the arti­cle you linked. The 97% rate for broc­coli is the high end of the range of test­ing (74-97%), and only applied when the microwaved broc­coli was immersed in water. Also, when it is claimed that there is con­tro­versy regard­ing the health con­cerns of microwaves–there is not. There really is little debate on the health con­cerns of microwaves. Most that claim true danger are little more than crack-​pots. Granted, there are dan­gers to using microwaves (on the other hand, there are also added safeties), but those are well-​documented and users should learn about these. as they would any other prod­uct they use in their house.

    It’s quite easy to bash microwaves or any other tech­no­log­i­cal break­through, but it’s impor­tant to do a bit of research, so that we can do what is best for our fam­i­lies.

    [Reply]

    Lindsay replied on May 1st, 2008:

    Eliz­a­beth,

    It is appar­ent that you missed the inten­tion of my post. My goal was to just share a few points that were of inter­est to note, not that I know the full truth of the matter. Thanks for shar­ing the link, its one of the first I have seen on the pos­i­tive side, and I have indeed been doing a lot of research on it, and have not made a rash deci­sion (in fact, I have been mulling over this for sev­eral months now). I made a few errors on my links, and have cor­rected them above.

    Per­son­ally, I have decided it is best for our family to live with­out a microwave, and in fact I have come to really enjoy it…but every­one is at lib­erty to make the best deci­sion they can.

    Another thing to note…try not to use plas­tic or ziplocs for heat­ing food in the microwave. This can leach chem­i­cals into your food.

    [Reply]

  4. Alissa Says:

    Hi Lind­say,

    Just wanted to let you know that you inspired me to take the plunge and buy a toaster oven. :) My hus­band and I have dis­cussed it on occa­sion before, but after read­ing your won­der­ful post about how ver­sa­tile this appli­ance is, we went ahead and bought one. I find there is a bit of a learn­ing curve with it, but noth­ing too steep. We man­aged to set off the smoke detec­tor last night while toast­ing bagels… so we turned it down some. :) We’re going to try to avoid using our microwave as much as pos­si­ble to see if we can ulti­mately do with­out it - if for no other reason than to free up some counter space. :)

    Thanks & take care,
    Alissa

    [Reply]

  5. Farrah Says:

    Can you give me some ideas on using a toaster oven. My hus­band gave me a KitchenAid one for Mother’s Day and I’m not sure how to use it. I had hoped to make pizza with it, but it isn’t big enough. Any other ideas?
    Thanks

    [Reply]

    Lindsay replied on May 11th, 2008:

    Farrah,
    Here is a list of some of the things I use my toaster oven for. Your manual should also give you ideas and instruc­tions.
    -Reheating/warming - I will put left­overs in for a quick reheat on a plate or glass con­tainer. The warm set­ting works great for this.
    -Toasting bread
    -De-thawing - if I forget to pull out some­thing frozen, I just put it in on bake for 10-15 min and that works to dethaw a bit.
    -Cooking pota­toes or roast­ing small amounts of vegis
    -Cooking an 8×8 casse­role

    You simply cook with it as you would a normal oven, except it will nor­mally cook faster, so keep an eye on it. Have fun!

    [Reply]

  6. mama Says:

    I did not know there was an easy alter­na­tive to the microwave! I wish I had thought of a toaster oven before I bought a brand new micro a few months ago!

    [Reply]

  7. Hari Says:

    Thank you for the infor­ma­tion. Now think­ing of buying a toaster oven but being an Indian we are not famil­iar to baking. I have few queries regard­ing the usage of toaster oven
    1:Can I use pyrex bake­ware in toaster oven?
    2:Can I bake a cake or pizza using a toaster oven?
    thanks in advance.

    [Reply]

    Lindsay replied on July 28th, 2008:

    Sorry for the delay in respond­ing to your com­ment. Yes, you can use pyrex bake­ware in the toaster oven. The size of your toaster oven will depend upon if you can bake a cake or pizza in it. I cannot, except for an 8×8 round cake pan works fine. Most toaster ovens are not tall enough for a bundt cake or some­thing along those lines. Some ovens come with a pizza tray, but it would be on the smaller side. Hope that helps!

    [Reply]

  8. researcher Says:

    I just fin­ished research­ing Pyrex and found var­i­ous sources that say NOT to use it in toaster ovens. As they also men­tion not “Pyrexing” for broil­ing, I assume it’s b/c it puts the dish too close to the ele­ment for safety/maintaining the integrity of the glass prod­uct. Hope that’s help­ful!

    [Reply]

  9. researcher Says:

    FYI, I found this info in an Amazon cus­tomer review of the 6-piece dish and lid Pyrex rectangular/square set and through a Google search–some­thing like “Pyrex toaster oven.” Hope that helps!

    [Reply]

Leave a Reply